Will a Dismissed Charge Appear on a Background Check?
The short answer is: it depends. Whether a dismissed charge shows up on a background check hinges on several factors, making it crucial to understand the nuances of the legal system and background check processes. While a dismissal ideally signifies the end of a legal matter, its impact on background checks isn't always straightforward.
What is a Dismissed Charge?
Before diving into the complexities of background checks, let's clarify what a dismissed charge means. A dismissed charge is a criminal accusation that the prosecution has formally dropped. This can happen for various reasons, including:
- Insufficient evidence: The prosecution might lack enough compelling evidence to proceed with the case.
- Witness unavailability: Key witnesses may be unavailable or unreliable, hindering the prosecution's ability to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Prosecutorial discretion: Prosecutors have the authority to dismiss cases, even if some evidence exists, based on various factors, including the severity of the crime, the defendant's history, and available resources.
- Plea bargain: The defendant may agree to a plea bargain on a lesser charge, leading to the dismissal of the original, more serious charge.
Types of Dismissals and Their Impact
Not all dismissals are created equal. The type of dismissal significantly influences whether it will appear on a background check:
-
With Prejudice: This is a final dismissal, meaning the charges cannot be refiled. Even so, some background check providers may still include it in their reports, often with a notation indicating it was dismissed.
-
Without Prejudice: This type of dismissal allows the prosecution to refile the charges at a later date if new evidence emerges. This is much more likely to appear on a background check because it suggests unresolved issues.
Which Background Checks Show Dismissed Charges?
Different background check types reveal varying levels of detail. Here’s a breakdown:
-
Criminal Background Checks: These are the most common type and may include dismissed charges, particularly those dismissed without prejudice or those where the dismissal occurred later in the process. The level of detail varies greatly depending on the provider and the jurisdiction.
-
Federal Background Checks: These checks are usually more thorough and might even include dismissed charges, especially if they involved a federal offense.
-
State-Level Background Checks: State laws differ significantly. Some states may include dismissed charges, while others might not, leading to inconsistencies in results.
What to Do if a Dismissed Charge Appears
If a dismissed charge appears on your background check, understand that it doesn't necessarily reflect poorly on you. However, the presence of even a dismissed charge can create concerns for potential employers or landlords. Consider the following:
-
Review the Report Carefully: Check for accuracy and ensure the dismissal is clearly indicated.
-
Explain the Circumstances: If applying for a job or housing, be prepared to explain the situation honestly and transparently. Focus on the reasons for the dismissal and any steps you've taken since then to demonstrate your rehabilitation.
-
Seek Legal Advice: If you believe the information is inaccurate or unfairly impacting your opportunities, consult with an attorney.
Can I Remove a Dismissed Charge from My Background Check?
You generally can't directly remove a dismissed charge from a background check. The information comes from official records. However, focusing on your positive attributes and addressing any potential concerns proactively can mitigate the impact.
FAQs
H2: How long will a dismissed charge remain on my background check?
The length of time a dismissed charge remains on your record varies by state and the type of background check. Some jurisdictions have time limits, while others may retain the information indefinitely.
H2: Will a dismissed charge affect my chances of getting a job?
It depends on the employer, the job, and the circumstances of the dismissal. Some employers may overlook a dismissed charge, particularly if it was for a minor offense and occurred many years ago. Others may have stricter policies.
H2: Does a dismissed charge affect my ability to own a firearm?
Federal law prohibits firearm ownership for individuals convicted of certain crimes. Even dismissed charges related to these offenses might still impact eligibility. Consult with a legal professional for clarity on this complex topic.
In conclusion, the appearance of a dismissed charge on a background check is far from guaranteed, and its impact depends on numerous factors. Understanding the different types of dismissals and how background check providers handle this information is key to navigating this potentially sensitive situation. If you have concerns, seeking legal counsel is always recommended.
